Child Sacrifice at Carthage and in Israel

Mesha Stele

Image: “The Mesha Stele” also known as “The Moabite Stone”

In their article, “Phoenician Bones of Contention,” published in the journal Antiquity, Volume 87, Issue 338 (December 2013): 1199-1207, Paolo Xella, Josephine Quinn, Valentina Melchiorri, and Peter van Dommelen argue that the bones found at Carthage are evidence that human sacrifices were made at the Topheth, the sacred place dedicated to the goddess Tanit.

Although scholars have debated whether the ancient burial places where thousands of urns containing the remains of cremated infants were evidence of child sacrifice or only a child cemetery, a group of academics have concluded that the evidence found at Cartage proves without any doubt that the Carthaginians did indeed sacrifice their children to their gods.

In a report released by the University of Oxford, Josephine Quinn said:

It’s becoming increasingly clear that the stories about Carthaginian child sacrifice are true. This is something the Romans and Greeks said the Carthaginians did and it was part of the popular history of Carthage in the 18th and 19th centuries.

But in the 20th century, people increasingly took the view that this was racist propaganda on the part of the Greeks and Romans against their political enemy, and that Carthage should be saved from this terrible slander.

What we are saying now is that the archaeological, literary, and documentary evidence for child sacrifice is overwhelming and that instead of dismissing it out of hand, we should try to understand it.

People have tried to argue that these archaeological sites are cemeteries for children who were stillborn or died young, but quite apart from the fact that a weak, sick or dead child would be a pretty poor offering to a god, and that animal remains are found in the same sites treated in exactly the same way, it’s hard to imagine how the death of a child could count as the answer to a prayer.

It’s very difficult for us to recapture people’s motivations for carrying out this practice or why parents would agree to it, but it’s worth trying.

Perhaps it was out of profound religious piety, or a sense that the good the sacrifice could bring the family or community as a whole outweighed the life of the child.

It is difficult for people today to understand the motive behind child sacrifice. To the modern mind, child sacrifice would be considered a barbaric ritual that should be unacceptable in any situation. People today would be unable to understand the need for child sacrifice or find any justification for this barbaric rite.

However, child sacrifice, although a practice that is unacceptable today and would be considered a crime in almost any society in our civilized world, must be understood from the perspective of the social, cultural, and religious context of the people who believed that it was an acceptable religious practice.

Child sacrifice, when looked at from the perspective of the parent who was sacrificing his or her child to a god, was an act of pious faith. The sacrifice of children was considered to be a deep demonstration of faith that came out of deep religious conviction. The dedication of one’s child to a god or goddess was accompanied by a solemn ritual that was performed at the Tophet, the sacred place where child sacrifice was performed.

In antiquity, many people believed that the sacrifice of human lives was the greatest gift one could offer to the gods. Many reasons motivated people to make a human sacrifice to the gods. Some of these reasons include the desire to please the gods, the request for a special favor, a desire to obtain better crops, or as an atonement for one’s sins.

According to the narrative found in the book of Kings, Mesha, the king of Moab offered his son to Chemosh, his god, in order to obtain a victory against Israel: “When the king of Moab saw that the battle was going against him, . . . he took his firstborn son who was to succeed him, and offered him as a burnt offering on the wall” (2 Kings 3:26-27).

Some people in ancient Israel believed in and practiced child sacrifice. The people’s rhetoric question to Micah the prophet reflects a popular belief that child sacrifice was one way by which they could atone for their sins: “With what shall I come before the LORD, and bow myself before God on high? . . . Shall I give my firstborn for my transgression, the fruit of my body for the sin of my soul?” (Micah 6:6-7).

Jephthah sacrificed his daughter in order to pay his vow to the Lord: “Jephthah made a vow to the LORD, and said, ‘If you will give the Ammonites into my hand, then whoever comes out of the doors of my house to meet me, when I return victorious from the Ammonites, shall be the LORD’s, to be offered up by me as a burnt offering’” (Judges 11:30-31). When he returned victorious from the battlefield, he “did with her according to the vow he had made” (Judges 11:39).

Even some of the kings of Judah sacrificed their children as an offering to pagan gods. Ahaz “made his son pass through fire, according to the abominable practices of the nations whom the LORD drove out before the people of Israel” (2 Kings 16:3). Manasseh “made his son pass through fire” (2 Kings 21:6).

Although some scholars believe that the expression “pass through fire” does not refer to human sacrifice, the biblical evidence clearly suggests that these two kings practiced child sacrifice because the Deuteronomic historian accused them of following the pagan practice of other nations.

Ruthann Birr, one of my former students at Northern Baptist Seminary, in her paper, “Child Sacrifice in the Old Testament,” written for my class on the Former Prophets, wrote the following about child sacrifice at Carthage [references omitted]:

Through the archaeological excavations at Carthage in 1921, we are given some of the best verification and understanding of the existence of the rite of child sacrifice within the context of the Phoenician culture. The largest cemetery of sacrificed infants in the ancient Near East ever discovered was unearthed here.

Founded in 814 B.C., Carthage began as a fledgling colony of Phoenicia but had developed into the center of Punic power by the fourth and third centuries B.C. With the founding of this city also came the infamous rite of child sacrifice imbedded in the religion of Phoenicia honoring their gods.

Hundreds of burial urns containing cremated remains of children – from newborn infants to children up to six years of age – as well as animals have been documented at the Carthage burial site. Based on the density of the excavated area, it is estimated “as many as 20,000 urns may have been deposited there between 400 and 200 B.C.”

The connection of this site to ritual sacrifice comes from the many inscriptions found on the burial monument accompanying these urns: inscriptions of the name or symbol of the Phoenician goddess Tanit (often identified with Astarte, the eastern Mediterranean goddess) and of Ba’al Hammon, the main patriarch of the Phoenician gods.

A typical example of one of the inscriptions reads: “To our lady, to Tanit, the face of Ba’al and to our lord, to Ba’al Hammon that which was vowed (by) PN [personal name] son of PN son of PN. Because he (the deity) heard his (the dedicant’s) voice and blessed him.”

Child sacrifice at Carthage was offered at the Topheth, a word whose meaning is unknown. Scholars believe that the word means “fireplace” or “hearth,” but its true etymology is uncertain.

The people of Judah practiced child sacrifice to Molech at the Topheth that was in the Hinnom Valley. According to Jeremiah, in the valley of the sons of Hinnom, the people of Judah burned “their children in the fire as burnt offerings to Baal” (Jeremiah 19:5). During the Deuteronomic religious reforms in the seventh century B.C., Josiah, in his attempt at eliminating syncretistic practices from the religion of Yahweh, “defiled Topheth, which is in the valley of Ben-hinnom, so that no one would make a son or a daughter pass through fire as an offering to Molech” (2 Kings 23:10).

So detestable was the practice of child sacrifice in Israel that Jeremiah prophesied that the Valley of Hinnom would become “the valley of Slaughter” (Jeremiah 7:32), because there the Lord would judge and punish those who engaged in child sacrifice.

In Hebrew, the expression “valley of Hinnom” is gê’ hinnōm, an expression that appears in the New Testament as “Gehenna,” the place where the wicked would suffer punishment and be destroyed. Jesus said: “Do not be afraid of those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul; rather, be afraid of the one who can destroy both soul and body in Gehenna” (Matthew 10:28 NAB).

In one of Jeremiah’s oracles, the Lord condemned the practice of child sacrifice: “And they go on building the high place of Topheth, which is in the valley of the son of Hinnom, to burn their sons and their daughters in the fire– which I did not command, nor did it come into my mind” (Jeremiah 7:31).

Thus, when speaking of child sacrifice in the Bible, one must remember what God said about child sacrifice: “That is something I never commanded them to do! Indeed, it never even entered my mind to command such a thing” (Jeremiah 7:31 NET).

UPDATE:

In a comment to my post, Peter Bekins called to my attention that the Mesha Stele does not make any reference to child sacrifice (see his comment below). The reference to Mesha’s sacrificing his son appears only in the narratives found in the book of Kings. I have made a correction to my post in order to reflect this fact about the Mesha Stele.

Claude Mariottini
Professor of Old Testament
Northern Baptist Seminary

If you enjoyed reading this post, share it with others: click the “Like” button and then share it:
facebook twitter

This entry was posted in 2 Kings, Archaeology, Book of 2 Kings, Canaanites, Children, Jeremiah, Josiah and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to Child Sacrifice at Carthage and in Israel

  1. Almond says:

    Shalom, Professor.

    You pointed out that atonement for sin was one of the reasons that motivated the ancient pagans to make human sacrifices to thier gods.

    Sir, how could we view Jesus’ sacrifice as not a form of the very same human sacrifice to a god hated by the True God ( Deuteronomy 12:31, 18:10 etc)?

    • Almond,

      There is a difference between child sacrifice and the death of Christ on the cross. In child sacrifice, people offer their children in order to gain favors with what we call “pagan gods.” The death of Jesus on the cross was a death in which he gave himself to die in the place of sinful humanity. Jesus said: “I lay down my life in order to take it up again. No one takes it from me, but I lay it down of my own accord” (John 10:17-18). Jesus’ death was not child sacrifice. In his death, he took your place and my place since it takes life for life to make atonement for sin.

      Thank you for visiting my blog.

      Claude Mariottini

  2. Antonia says:

    Great post – thanks! God did, though, command a child sacrifice (though of an older child, and although He did not permit the command to be completely followed through upon) – when He commanded Abraham to offer Isaac. In fact, when my now-husband, who was raised in Judaism, became a believer in Messiah Jesus, his rabbi asked to meet with him, and in an effort to convince my husband not to follow Jesus and to convince him that the Bible isn’t really true, he said, “…For example, God would never have truly commanded Abraham, a father, to kill Isaac, his son. God doesn’t do that to families.” But, God did, for His own wise reasons in this particular instance!

    The mercy of God provided the sacrificial ram, instead. So, it is true that God never commanded and required the follow-through. Perhaps this complete meaning is what is intended in the Jeremiah 7:31 passage. He never commanded it, in the sense of “commanded AND required” it.

    I often wonder what that episode did to Isaac’s relationship with his dad. The rabbi’s words did make me stop and think. Nevertheless, I believe the Holy Writ of God, rather than to doubt merely because of my own speculations and concerns. Ultimately, God’s commands are for a blessing and not for harm, so whatever occurred between Abraham and Isaac, God our great Healer and the Mender of families was able to, and is in the afterlife, able to provide any healing and understanding that each of them would need to have to get over the shock of that episode. The fact that Isaac continued on with his faith in God intact certainly does seem to underscore that God protected him from feelings of unresolved betrayal, anger, or hurt, at least enough so that he didn’t see fit to reject the God Who had commanded this.

    Perhaps the fact that child sacrifice abounded in ancient times was enough to desensitize him to some of the trauma that would occur if the event had transpired today. I’m not sure of the timing of the initiation of child sacrifice and whether it was extant in the days of Abraham. Does anyone know what the earliest approximate date of known child sacrifice might have been? I’m not well-versed on the dates of the societies mentioned in today’s blog, but they all do seem considerably later than the time of Abraham. I’m just curious. It would certainly shed some light on why (perhaps) Isaac didn’t reject his father, and his father’s God, after the “akedah” (binding of Isaac). I really have often wondered about Isaac’s frame of mind after that and how he was able to resolve it. To have had child sacrifice taking place around him in other families and cultures would seem to somehow “normalize” it a bit, at least, more so than in modern society!

    Thank you again for the post!

    • Antonia,

      Thank you for your thoughtful comment. Scholars believe that the story of Abraham’s sacrifice of Isaac is a polemic against child sacrifice in the religion of Israel. As to what happened to Isaac, I encourage you to read my post on the Akedah. Here is the link: http://claudemariottini.com/2013/09/04/the-trial-of-abraham/. You should also read Leon Kass’ treatment of the Akedah. His book is mentioned in my post.

      Since you enjoyed reading my post, I invite you to subscribe to my blog and receive my posts by email. I write on Old Testament themes and seek to clarify difficult passages in the Hebrew Bible. Look at by Archive page. There you will find many posts that I am sure you will enjoy reading.

      Claude Mariottini

      • Antonia says:

        Dear Dr. Mariottini,
        Thank you for your wonderful reply! I will definitely chase down those additional readings to which you referred. I have already with tremendous delight signed up for your blog; this is how I came across today’s blog! It is a wondrous thing to meet someone so thoughtful and well-balanced about the Old Testament. I look eagerly forward to savoring the light that the Lord will shed for me upon tricky O.T. passages through your prayerful and considered writings. Thank you for all of the time that you invest in them. I do not for the life of me know how a college professor does this!

        Blessings in our dear Lord Jesus Christ,
        Antonia

      • Antonia,

        Thank you for your nice words. I am glad to know that you are receiving my posts by email. I am always open for conversation. If you have any question about the Old Testament, I am here to help you.

        Claude Mariottini

  3. Peter Bekins says:

    I don’t believe the Mesha Stele makes any reference to child sacrifice; it is only the story in Kings that you cited. This is usually understood as a polemic on behalf of the Israelite author to paint the Moabites as barbarians, though that assumes a modern cultural attitude toward child sacrifice as the authors of the recent Carthage study note and the text is also strangely silent on why the sacrifice worked. For a possible reference to child sacrifice in inscriptional material see the Incirli trilingual: http://balshanut.wordpress.com/2009/01/26/kaufman-stephen-a-the-phoenician-inscription-of-the-incirli-trilingual-a-tentative-reconstruction-and-translation-maarav-1422007-7-26/

    • Peter,

      Thank you for calling my attention to my mistake about child sacrifice in the Mesha Stele. After reading your comment, I checked ANET and sure enough, there is no reference to child sacrifice there. I will make a correction to my post in order to avoid disseminating false information about the Mesha Stela.

      I checked Balshanut. Have you stopped blogging? Again, thank you for your comment.

      Claude Mariottini

      • Peter Bekins says:

        Claude, I have not officially stopped blogging, but the demands of teaching and research (in hopes of finding actual employment) are monopolizing my time. I will probably try to post a short series this summer, as I did last summer.

      • Peter,

        I enjoyed reading some of your posts. I will look with anticipation for your new posts.

        Claude Mariottini

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s