The Rabbis’ View on Huldah the Prophetess

For the past few weeks I have been writing a series of posts on the women prophets in the Old Testament. The list of posts on these amazing Old Testament women is given below.

Although some of my readers have disagreed with my view that these women lived in a patriarchal society, a society which limited what women could do, the reality is that very few women enjoyed positions of leadership in ancient Israelite society.

In her book The Creation of Patriarchy, Gerda Lerner wrote:

A number of recent studies of the role of women in the Old Testament have tried to balance the overwhelming evidence of patriarchal domination by citing a few female heroic figures or women who take independent action of one sort or another. Phyllis Trible has even asserted the existence of a “counter-culture” to the “patriarchal culture of Israel.” In an interpretive essay which details the various expressions of patriarchal dominance in the Old Testament, another feminist scholar, Phyllis Bird, states correctly, as her evidence shows, that women are legally and economically deemed inferior to man in the Biblical narrative and that this reflected actual conditions in Hebrew society. Nevertheless, she asserts that man in the Old Testament recognizes woman “as his opposite and equal,” an assertion for which she offers precious little evidence.

The few women mentioned as having a respected or heroic role are quite overwhelmed by the many women described in servile, submissive, or subordinate roles. Clearly, the narrative, especially in the Song of Deborah and in the reference to the prophetess Huldah, lends support to the statement that women were recognized as prophetesses. But when we place these narratives in chronological order, it appears that this was so in the early period of Hebrew history, before or shortly after state formation. In the monarchy and thereafter we do not find women in such roles (1986:176).

This patriarchal view of women in leadership roles continued even into rabbinical times. In his article, “Huldah, the Deuteronomic Prophetess of the Book of Kings,” Tal Ilan describes how the rabbis viewed Deborah and Ruth. Ilan wrote:

It should come as no surprise though that a later evaluation of Deborah’s story does much to diminish her role. The rabbis, for example, take issue with her name – bee. They view it as a reflection of her negative character traits. They couple Deborah with the other prophetess – Huldah, whose name refers to an even more repulsive animal – a weasel. They say: “There were two arrogant women whose names were hateful. One was named ‘wasp’ (in Aramaic זיבורתא ) and the other ‘rat’ (in Aramaic כרכושתא). Of the wasp it is written: ‘She sent and summoned Barak’ (Judges 4:6) rather than go to him. Of the rat it is written: ‘Tell the man’ (2 Kings 22:15) rather than ‘tell the king’ ” (b. Megillah 14b). Probably because in their time, a woman in such a position was unthinkable, even more than the biblical authors, the rabbis were disturbed by women attaining such power and they attributed them disagreeable personal traits because they didn’t like their success.

Patriarchy was a reality in ancient Israel, but the patriarchal view of women breaks down in the case of the women prophets. The reason is that while most positions of leadership were chosen by men or were past from father to son, the prophet was a person called by God. Thus, when the spirit of God chooses an individual to the prophetic ministry, God does not look at the gender of that individual. God can choose both men and women to proclaim his message to people who do not know him.

Claude Mariottini
Professor of Old Testament
Northern Baptist Seminary

Note:

If you are unable to see the Hebrew letters in the essay, download the Biblical fonts and install them on your computer. Download the fonts here.

Other Posts on Women Prophets:

Women Prophets in the Hebrew Bible

Isaiah’s Wife

Deborah the Prophetess

Huldah the Prophetess

Bibliography:

Ilan, Tal. “Huldah, the Deuteronomic Prophetess of the Book of Kings.” Lectio Difficilior 1/2010. http://www.lectio.unibe.ch.

Lerna, Gerda. The Creation of Patriarchy. New York: Oxford University Press, 1986.

 

This entry was posted in Deborah, Huldah, Prophetess, Women and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to The Rabbis’ View on Huldah the Prophetess

  1. Heather Stephens says:

    Again, thank you Dr, Mariottini. You know what you are talking about. Thank the Lord Jesus Christ.

    Like

    • Heather,

      Thank you for your comment. I apologize for the delay in answering your comment. My blog was out for several days for repairs.

      I am glad your are enjoying the posts on the women prophets in the Old Testament. This week I will posts my study on Miriam the prophetess.

      Claude Mariottini

      Like

  2. Pingback: Judith in Her ‘Increasing Fame’ as the Prophetess Huldah | Huldah The Prophetess

  3. Pingback: Judith in Her ‘Increasing Fame’ as the Prophetess Huldah | A Historical Commentary on the Book of Judith

  4. Pingback: Judith in Her ‘Increasing Fame’ as the Prophetess Huldah | Jeremiah The Prophet Of God

  5. Pingback: Juditha Triumphans | AMAIC Humanities

  6. Pingback: Judith and Huldah | Parallel Lives, Also BC Afterglows In AD

  7. Pingback: Judith in Her ‘Increasing Fame’ as the Prophetess Huldah | Prophet Jeremiah and Era of Nebuchednezzar II

  8. Pingback: Prophet Jeremiah and Era of Nebuchednezzar II

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s